
The battle on Mount Carmel in 1 Kings 18 is one of the great showdowns in the Bible, Elijah against 450 prophets of Baal with fire falling from heaven. It’s the stuff of Sunday school flannelgraphs.
But the real battle that day was going on inside the people watching it.
They knew the old stories of what the Lord had done for them, the Exodus and everything after. They also knew how their neighbors lived, and they didn’t want to fall behind. The Canaanites worshiped Baal, the god of rain and fertility, and they seemed to be doing fine. So Israel hedged their bets.
Now Baal had failed them. There had been no rain for three years, and the land was ruined. They had to decide. Who is our God?
Every one of us runs into that same question eventually. Sooner or later our false gods let us down, and we have to choose.
You can’t see yourself clearly without God
When King Ahab finally met Elijah, the first thing he did was blame him.
When Ahab saw Elijah, Ahab said to him, “Is it you, you troubler of Israel?” And he answered, “I have not troubled Israel, but you have, and your father’s house, because you have abandoned the commandments of the LORD and followed the Baals.” (1 Kings 18:17–18)
Ahab was sure the prophet was the problem. Sin does that. It shifts the blame. Without God’s word in front of us we can’t see the truth about ourselves, and we’ll always find some troublemaker to point at.
A la carte faith
Then Elijah stood up in front of the people.
And Elijah came near to all the people and said, “How long will you go limping between two different opinions? If the LORD is God, follow him; but if Baal, then follow him.” And the people did not answer him a word. (1 Kings 18:21)
These people weren’t atheists, and they hadn’t rejected the Lord. They worshiped Him for cultural reasons, because He was the God of their parents. They worshiped Baal for practical reasons, because Baal was supposed to bring fertile fields and herds and families.
Call it a la carte faith. It’s like ordering the burger combo and then swapping the fries for a salad and the soda for a shake. I’ll take God, but my way.
And that runs straight into the first commandment: “You shall have no other gods before me” (Exodus 20:3).
The gods we use
We don’t set up Baal poles anymore, but we still keep idols for the same reason Israel did, which is to get what we want. Here are a few of the usual suspects.
- Materialism. We pray to it believing it can make us happy.
- Comfort. If it’s easy, it must be right.
- Emotion. If it feels good, it must be God. We ride the high when worship is moving and then fall apart when God disciplines us and the feelings go flat. Emotions are great servants and terrible masters.
- Self. This is the private faith that never shows up on a Tuesday, the Christian who never joins a church. That’s a little like a soldier who won’t join an army, or a football player without a team, or a bee without a hive.
- Marginal obedience. Doing just enough to stay in good standing, and not one step more.
Every one of these is a god we use. The trouble is that the true God is too big to be used. He isn’t going to be one option on the menu.
Martin Luther had a simple test for finding your real god. In his Large Catechism, explaining the first commandment, he said your god is whatever you set your heart on and put your trust in. So forget what you say you believe on Sunday. What do you lean on when Monday goes wrong?
That now, I say, upon which you set your heart and put your trust is properly your god.
Silence is a choice
“And the people did not answer him a word.”
That silence says a lot. Not choosing feels safe, like you’re just keeping your options open. But not choosing is still a choice.
There’s an old fable about a war between the birds and the beasts, and the bat couldn’t make up his mind. When the birds came by, he said, “I’m a beast.” When the beasts came by, he said, “I’m a bird.” When peace was finally made, neither side would have him. He’d spent so long playing both sides that he belonged to neither.
Wavering leaves you out in the cold just like that bat.
Decide who your God is
I’m not saying obedience is easy, or that God’s will is always simple to figure out, or that being all-in for Jesus is a breeze. I am saying you can settle, once and for all, who your God is. Then every decision doesn’t turn into a fresh vote on who you’ll obey this time.
Be honest with yourself about a few questions.
- When something goes wrong, where do I run first?
- What do I believe I can’t be happy without?
- Where am I doing “just enough” with God?
- Who would I be if that thing were taken away?
If you’ve been limping between two opinions, come home. The Lord is God. Follow Him.
Enjoyed this article?